Moths, Butterflies and Ethical Questions
I read Patricia Grace's short story, "Butterflies " years ago in college, and it has stayed with me all this time. In it, a little girl writes a story for school about how she killed all the butterflies. The teacher is appalled. Her grandfather observes later that the teacher must not grow her own cabbages. I have grown my own cabbages (and collards and kale and other brassicas), and must admit to some inconsistency on the matter. I can't bring myself to kill the cabbage white butterflies. However, I have no problem flinging their looper caterpillars, which are just the baby butterflies after all, off my plants and to their doom under the bird feeder. To be fair, I grow only a tiny bit of my own food, for fun and to help the environment a little. If I had to rely more on my own cabbages to feed a grandchild, I would undoubtedly have a different attitude altogether. Ethics can be a matter of perspective. I started pondering all this again the other day when I found t...